Sounds from the Underworld

Katharine Payne Photo: David Rendall

Katharine Payne
Photo: David Rendall

So grateful to have been on the video crew for Returning Current at the Music Gallery last week with Video Vitamin!

I arrived early last week to the Music Gallery- a space especially beautiful and haunting when empty. Duo Daniela Gesundheit and Dan Goldman (Snowblink) with Leslie Feist and choir in collaboration with bioacoustics researcher Katharine Payne weaved an interspecies concert of mammalian music.

Daniela Gesundheit, Leslie Feist and choir Photo: David Rendall

Daniela Gesundheit, Leslie Feist and choir
Photo: David Rendall

Payne revealed years of audio research on humpback whales and African elephants, while Daniela and the choir used their voices to teach us about the rhythms and patterns of these otherworldly creatures. 

Memoria Palermo: A Personal Story of Disappearance and Memory

Poster for the Memorial of Alberto J. Munarriz and Rolando E. Adem

Poster for the Memorial of Alberto J. Munarriz and Rolando E. Adem

While reporting for The Argentina Independent in Buenos Aires in March, one day I received an email out of the blue from a friend whose family has a personal connection. He invited me to attend a memorial service for members of his family. I had been taught the current affairs and the history of the country, with emphasis on the dictatorship of 1976-1983 under Jorge Rafael Videla, Roberto Viola and Leopoldo Galtieri and the atrocities of this time are written about endlessly. But to take a closer look at a personal story from those who were actually there was a unique experience I was honoured to have. The following is a brief interview with Susana Munarriz, sister, wife and friend of the men being commemorated, followed by photos from the ceremony.

What was your relationship to the 2 men being commemorated?
SM: Alberto Jose Munarriz was my brother and Rolando E. Adem was my husband at the time.

What happened to them?
SM: Alberto disappeared on the 14th of November 1974 at the age of 28 years old. Rolando disappeared on the 16th of March the following year at the age of 26.

Could you tell me a bit about their backgrounds as individuals?
SM: Alberto was born in 1946. He was the oldest of three children and the only boy of a middle class family living in Buenos Aires. After finishing high school in the Liceo Naval, a high school run by the Argentine Navy, he began studying business administration but soon lost interest in the field and went on to study journalism. Since childhood he was an avid reader.

MemoriaPalermoIn his 20s he developed a strong interest in social issues, history and politics. He had very close family ties, excellent relations with his parents as well as with his sisters and extended family. As a hobby he studied to become a glider pilot. In 1970, he spent three years as a political prisoner under the military dictatorship of that time. Released in 1973 under a democratic government, he again enjoyed his freedom until November 1974 when he was kidnapped and disappeared just a few days before the government of Isabel Peron decree State of Siege.

MemoriaPalermo - Version 2Rolando was the youngest of four children born to a middle class family in Buenos Aires. After finishing high school, he spent time working on his parents’ ranch in the southwest region of the country. He later worked in Buenos Aires and become involved with labour organizations. He married Alberto’s sister in 1972. He was a very resourceful individual with a special love for the countryside and was particularly sensitive to the hardships and conditions of the rural workers. He and his wife were active in human rights organizations that defended and assisted political prisoners.

What were the circumstances regarding their disappearances? Why might they have been targeted?
SM: We don’t know the exact circumstances as to how they were kidnapped. In Alberto’s case, we received information that he was taken away from inside a restaurant in the city of Buenos Aires by security forces in civilian clothes. Rolando was kidnapped near Hurlingham train station in the suburbs of Buenos Aires by members of the secret police. They were both targeted because of their political ideas and their activism in denouncing the policies of repression and social injustice of the military and civilian government of the time. Both were members of a left wing political party.

Can you explain how you felt about the political climate at the time? Did you feel in danger yourself? 
SM: Absolutely. The social and political climate at that time was one of fear, censorship, persecution and repression. Testimony of which were the killings of well known politicians, lawyers and intellectual figures, and the kidnapping and disappearance of students, activists and members of the labour movement. There were thousands of political prisoners jailed without charges or legitimate judiciary process. As all other relatives of those killed or disappeared, we lived in constant fear.

Do you think Alberto or Rolando felt they were in danger?
SM: Most probably. It was a feeling shared by all those who were in some way or another opposed to the regime.

Have there been investigations since and have there been any successes in discovering the truth of what happened?
SM: Our family did numerous judiciary presentations denouncing their disappearances at the time it happened as well as later on and we continue to this day. During the military dictatorship of 1976-1983, their cases, along with thousands of others were taken to the UN, OAS and numerous other international human rights organizations. We are still waiting for the truth of what happened to them and still hopeful that justice will be done.

Do you think the current administration is making a sincere effort to commemorate those lost and to bring justice for Argentines affected?
SM: The current administration has taken serious steps to denounce the involvement of the military, civilian and security forces for their crimes again humanity and has facilitated the legal process for many organizations and individuals. Many accused have already been condemned by the courts and are facing harsh sentences. Granted this has been an important step on the road toward justice, but we are still looking for answers about the whereabouts of our loved ones.

Is there anything else you would like to say?
SM: Yes, I would like to point out that the struggle to get the complete truth and justice continues in Argentina and that we will never forget our loved ones and all those who are still missing.

Today, Amnesty International pegs the number of disappeared from Argentina at 15,000, however, many other sources insist the number is closer to 30,000. Memoria Palermo is a grassroots organization made up by people from the Palermo district- a neighbourhood of Buenos Aires- that decided to publicly commemorate disappeared people from the neighbourhood by installing pave stones with names on the side walks as a way of both remembering together, and reminding others. The stones are located near the homes, workplaces, schools and places last seen.

IMG_0318 - Version 2 IMG_0312 IMG_0230 - Version 2  

Día de la Memoria, Buenos Aires

DiaMemoriaSunday 24th March, tens of thousands demonstrated for Día de la Memoria, the 37th anniversary of the military coup which marked the beginning of Argentina’s last dictatorship, from 1976-83. Percussionists pounded their drums, children played in the streets, activists and theatrical supporters spontaneously performed stories of oppression and liberation. Thousands marched from the landmark Obelisk down Diagonal Norte and from 9 de Julio down Av. de Mayo to join the sea of people carrying posters with the images of the disappeared in Plaza de Mayo. Young people painted their bodies with the words ‘nunca mas’ (never again). This day truly had me in awe of the passion and unity of the people of Buenos Aires. The following is a collaborate photo essay, edited and published by myself  (other photographers: Simon Guerra and Julie Catarinella) >>>GO HERE>>>

Sala Alberdi- Public space. Public art.

Early in January, when increasing financial tensions and the prospect of privatization were threatening the integrity of the Centro Cultural General San Martín (CCGSM) in Buenos Aires, artists, students and friends put down more then just their feet- they laid down a fully equipped encampment and vowed to occupy the open space called Plaza Seca indefinitely.


Plaza Seca space is decorated with student art but remains open for free community workshops

Fenced off Centro Cultural General San Martín

Fenced off Centro Cultural General San Martín

Sala Alberdi was opened in 2006 by BA’s Arts & Education Department and has continued to operate out of the CCGSM. In its inception, Sala Alberdi provided theatre studies to some 43,000 people across the city and free children’s plays to thousands of public urban and rural schools.

communal kitchen

The communal kitchen has been moved as a result of it attracting too many people outside the movement looking for a bite to eat.

In 2010, after a number of cuts by the city government and many job losses, the Sala Alberdi artists decided to take over the space for themselves. Early this year, the city put up fences and locked out students and teachers of the organization. In the absence of answers, and in protest, on Jan. 5th of this year, a group of active members entered the space and have been squatting since.

GuitaristTheir numbers have grown and they continue to hold regular free workshops for the public on a daily basis. In exchange, they accept personal contributions and basic necessities for the camp. The court ruled they leave as of May 4th, 2012, but well…they’re still there. As a result, tensions have been mounting between squatters and the metro police, who have been accused of using unnecessary force.

Circus in the street

The government has upheld their position, but occupants insist it’s a violation of their rights. For now, they prefer to dance to the beat of the ‘Occupy’ drum being heard around the world. This weekend, I visited for a second time and spoke with Francisco- a musician who has just returned from a tour and is living in the camp indefinitely. He told me that about 4 of his friends (and members) have been locked in a room on the 6th floor without a washroom, food or facilities for 63 days. Their friends use a pulley system to send them food on the regular. They could leave, but their presence maintains the legitimacy of their strike, so they’re taking one (long one) for the team. In the coming months, temperatures could drop as low as -5 C, making the future of the settlement uncertain.

Carnaval Boedo, Buenos Aires

Every year, throughout the month of February (summertime), Buenos Aires exhibits 37 parades across the different ‘barrios’ (neighbourhoods) of the city.

All night long, exhibitionists of all ages and sizes show off their choreography and gem studded costumes to the sound of rumbling drums.

some young performers I caught while waiting for the bus. Notice how they smoothly hide their smokes.

Some young performers I caught while waiting for the bus. Notice how they smoothly hide their smokes.

These smaller, more local parades are called ‘Murgas’ and were declared Cultural Heritage of the city in 1997.

Child performers take a break

Performances are said (by organizers) to use humour to comment on the Argentinian culture.

Festivities run all night and into the morning hours.